Compare

Surplus vs Clicky Draft: two free baseball draft boards, different jobs

Surplus prices fantasy baseball picks in points. Clicky Draft is free/basic for TV draft parties and remote picks. Both can be free. They are not the same tool. Surplus is a product, not the surplus-value drafting strategy.

Local guest state No trackers Published methodology Works offline

Surplus is the free board at surplus.football that prices every pick in projected points and VOB. Clicky Draft is the free live-party board for TV and remote drafts. Clicky’s public site lists MLB leagues next to NFL, MLB, NBA, and NHL.

Side by side

Surplus

What: A draft board that prices picks in points.
Price: Free at surplus.football. Guest drafts stay in this browser. Surv% and Δ pick lock behind a free sign-up.
Best for: Proj, VOB, Tier, ADP, and the gap between model and market, on one board.
Room: HDMI or cast the Surplus tab. The commissioner records picks on that machine. There is no shareable room URL and no multi-owner sync. Surplus does not import Sleeper baseball leagues.
Value: Yes. Columns include Proj, VOB, Tier, ADP, Δ pick, Surv%, Inj, and eGP.

surplus.football

Clicky Draft

What: A live-party draft board for a TV and remote picks.
Price: Clicky Draft’s public pages list a free basic tier for live parties and remote drafts, plus paid upgrades.
Best for: Projecting a shared board to a TV while owners pick from their own devices.
Room: Clicky Draft’s public positioning is the shared party board: TV or projector, plus owners picking from a phone, tablet, or computer.
Value: Not positioned as a board that prices every pick in projected points and VOB.

clickydraft.com

Different jobs

If the question is “which free baseball board prices the pick,” the answer is Surplus. If the question is “which free board is built for a TV party with remote owners on the same room,” Clicky Draft’s free tier is the one built for that job.

Surplus is also not “surplus value,” the drafting strategy. It is the product at surplus.football. See the MLB FAQ.

FAQ

Is Surplus the same as surplus value drafting?

No. Surplus value is a strategy. Surplus is the free baseball board at surplus.football.

Does Clicky Draft price VOB?

Clicky’s public positioning is the live party board, not a value-over-replacement board.

Surplus — the draft board that prices picks in points.

Open the draft board